Gadgetell Review: Amazon Kindle
Gadgetell Quick Review:
Amazon Kindle
What is it?
The Amazon Kindle is Amazon’s electronic reading device. It uses E Ink technology and is available for $359.
Pros:
Easy to use, lightweight, lots of storage and free wireless service.
Cons:
The included cover needs improvement.
First Thoughts:
As an avid reader, I am a fan of both traditional and ebooks. For years I’ve enjoyed using the eReader software on my Palm devices, but the small screen and even smaller selection of ebooks available has always left a little something to be desired. When Amazon came out with their own ebook reader, called the Kindle, I was thrilled!
So were thousands of others, resulting in many waiting 3-4 months for theirs to be shipped. I wanted one but the price at the time ($399) was a bit prohibitive for me. It dropped to $359 and I was sorely tempted, but then Oprah had it on her show, declaring it her favorite gadget and offering a $50 discount code. That did it for me and I am now the proud owner of a Kindle!
Specs:
There’s a lot to love about this little gadget. It uses E Ink technology, which means the screen looks just like paper. It uses real ink that’s been electrically charged. There’s no backlight (E Ink screens are opaque making backlighting impossible), or color (the technology to make color E Ink is still in the early development stages and likely to be quite pricey) but you really don’t miss them.
There are plenty of lightweight reading lights available and let’s face it, most books are black and white anyway. The device holds 200 books, with back up storage provided via your Amazon account, and has an SD slot for even more storage. The battery lasts a week or more with Whispernet turned off and is user replaceable, which is a big plus. Recharging only takes two hours. It weighs a mere 10.6 ounces and has a 6 inch screen with 600x800 resolution.
Features:
The Kindle offers a full QWERTY keyboard, The New Oxford American Dictionary, access to Wikipedia and the Internet, and the ability to create bookmarks and make notes about what you’re reading. You can also send photos, text, Word and PDF documents to it, and it even plays audiobooks or MP3’s. The font is also adjustable up to 20pt.
Content:
The Kindle’s true strengths are in the large selection of books available for it (190,000 at this writing) and its built in wireless network, called Whispernet. Whispernet is run on Sprint’s EVDO network and it’s free. With it, users can download books in seconds, and can subscribe to electronic versions of an ever increasing selection of newspapers, magazines, and blogs. The Kindle’s keyboard makes searching easy.
The newspapers and magazines are much cheaper than the newsstand price (for example the Wall Street Journal is just $9.99 a month and Newsweek a mere $1.49 a month! Blog subscriptions run between .99 cents and $1.99 a month). Books can also be downloaded via a PC with the included USB cable. Whispernet also provides sample chapters, access to Wikipedia and even has a built in browser so you can surf the net and check email. (Note: Whispernet is not available in Montana, Alaska, or outside the U.S.) Don’t be fooled however, being an electronic reading device is what the Kindle does best, and the browser is rather primitive, even with sites that are mostly text.
Cons:
Its drawbacks are few. It does take a bit of time to get used to the page turning buttons but the automatic page turning feature helps quite a bit. The included leather cover is a real disappointment. It doesn’t hold the Kindle well at all, although wrapping the attached elastic band (which holds the cover closed when the Kindle is not in use) around the bottom right edge does help, and many Kindle users report attaching Velcro to the back also helps. Fortunately, there are many third party covers available.
Final Thoughts:
So what makes the Kindle better than traditional books? Nothing really—it’s the form factor that’s superior. You can carry your entire library on a device the size of a paperback - a real boon for those who travel a lot or like me, just don’t have anymore space available for books! Ebooks also cost a lot less. Amazon offers most new releases and NYT best sellers for just $9.99, and many other books are available for even less - some are even free!
There are even some textbooks available and you aren’t limited to the Kindle Store. There are many other sites offering Kindle compatible e-books. If you are an avid reader, I can’t recommend it enough! If you’re outside the U.S., you’re out of luck for now, as Amazon requires a U.S. address and credit card for purchase, but don’t fret. There is a U.K version in the works!
Keep up with the latest gadget goodness! -
Subscribe to our feed
Palm Pre Information & Updates
Palm just introduced their next-gen smartphone, the Palm Pre, and next-gen operating system, Palm webOS. Gadgetell's got the latest Pre and webOS information and news for you right here.




I really want to see a Kindle and give it a try. Do any stores carry this product so you can give it a test drive? Do you think the next generation Kindle will be released in 2009, with a lower price? I can’t justify $359 for this product quite yet; even $300 with Oprah’s discount code is still hefty.
on November 9, 2008 at 03:03 PM - LINKHi Lucy,
The Kindle is only available from Amazon.com, and I’m afraid Oprah’s discount expired on 11/1. The CEO of Amazon says the Kindle 2 won’t be released until late 2009 at the earliest. There’s no word on price but I would expect it to be around the same as the Kindle’s now. The E-ink technology isn’t cheap. Hope this helps!
P.S.- If you go to the Kindle product page on Amazon and click Kindle discussions, you’ll find an area called “See a Kindle in Your City.” which will let you find someone in your area willing to let you check out their Kindle. Good luck!
on November 9, 2008 at 06:20 PM - LINKUltimately my big problem with the Kindle is the proprietary format it uses for its books. Rather than use a standard that had already been adopted by other readers, and that Amazon actually owns (Mobipocket), Amazon, tweaked its format so that it would not be easy to read books bought for Kindles on any other device.
If ebook readers take off, I suspect that many will replace their readers every 3-4 years. If you use a Kindle you are stuck with replacing it with another kindle. Just because the Kindle might be the best reader at the moment, that doesn’t mean it will still be so in 5 years.
—
on November 17, 2008 at 03:11 PM - LINKBill